Skip to content

Science vs. religion: Mythology is poetry, not prose, by Heather Wiech

October 2, 2011
Education by Louis Comfort Tiffany

Wisdom is the marriage of science and religion.

image enhanced from Education by Louis Comfort Tiffany

How do you keep myth from becoming dogma?  Heather Wiech suggests it takes both science and religion.  –  B. T. Newberg

Joseph Campbell said that religion is supposed to give meaning to the science of the time. What has happened, though, is that religions of the text have placed all the emphasis on literal truth over the metaphorical value of the mythology. This has led religious people to fight against modern science to absurdity.  Hence, we are currently looking back at religion as something archaic and foolish.

The poetry of myth

In tribal cultures, mythology is alive.  It changes with the tribe.  As knowledge/geography/needs change, the mythology changes to reflect these.  In the modern era, mythology has stagnated.  The mythology that was meant to meet the needs of nomadic peoples of the Fertile Crescent no longer speaks to people in the age of technology.

Myth, according to Campbell, should provide guidance through the cycles of life and help to face uncertainty and adversity within a sort of “wisdom of the ages.” It also shows us a hero (Jesus, Buddha, Moses, Mohammed, Hercules, Superman, Neo, et cetera) who is a mirror of the hero in our own story: ourselves.

Myth speaks of our psychology. Gods are not external beings but rather symbols of pieces of our human psychology. What would a god need with jealousy, avarice, hubris? If it’s truly a higher being, nothing. It’s far more likely that it is a mirror of our folly in a symbolic language.

Mythology is poetry, not prose.

The meaning of ritual

Ritual is the physical acting out of a myth to attain a new level of consciousness or state of being. Today’s rituals, according to Campbell, are all watered-down compared to the mystery rituals of Demeter or the tribal manhood rituals. We’ve lost the meaning and purpose of ritual. People sitting in pews and drifting off to sleep while the priest drones on about scripture is not a ritual.

In tribal societies, manhood is something earned, not just grown into. A boy is ripped from the arms of his mother and thrown out into the wilderness to kill a beast alone. Once he has faced his trial, he is often marked with the experience on his body (tattoos, piercings, scarification, etc). Then he returns to the tribe as a man with all the rights and responsibilities associated.

What’s the equivalent today? A boy getting laid for the first time?

It’s no wonder adolescence continues far into adulthood.

No dogma

Myth and ritual are vital to human nature, and it is important to know what the two are and how they function for us, so as not to get stuck. We need to be very careful in how we implement them. It needs to remain a philosophical process if it is not to become dogma.

I think black-and-white “religion vs. science” is a false dichotomy. We need not throw out the baby with the bathwater. There is wisdom on both sides, and we don’t concede we are wrong by making use of what is good and valid. Science and mythology should work together rather than oppose each other, for wisdom is the marriage of the two.

The author

Heather Wiech

Heather Wiech

Heather Wiech is an international relations scholar, philosopher, human rights activist, blogger, tutor, culinary artist, photographer, techie nerd, mythology enthusiast, and spiritual naturalist.  http://heatherwiech.com

About these ads
10 Comments
  1. October 2, 2011 7:04 pm

    If you enjoy mythology, a book I highly recommend is “Trickster Makes This World,” by Lewis Hyde. Hyde interprets the trickster myths more in light of social and political situations, than Campbell’s typical psychological interpretations.

    I’m a big fan of Joseph Campbell, and I think his four volume “Masks of the Gods” is as good an introduction to world religions as you can get. But I think there are other approaches to mythology that sometimes get missed because Campbell is such a well known presence.

    Thomas

    • Arden White permalink
      October 7, 2011 4:25 pm

      “Trickster Makes This World” is truly phenomenal: at once fun, dense, and profound. I second.

    • Heather permalink
      October 9, 2011 6:51 am

      Thanks for the suggestions, Tom. :)

  2. October 4, 2011 8:24 pm

    I am very pleased with what I read as this is exactly how I feel on the issues raised on this blog post. Except the seeming suggestion of throwing our youth into the woods to kill something and get a body marking to become adults. :D

    Great article Heather!

    • Heather permalink
      October 7, 2011 4:30 pm

      Thanks, Rua. I didn’t exactly mean we should throw our youths to the wolves. I simply meant that we don’t make change to adulthood a real ritual anymore. There’s no trial, no test. They don’t even learn their rights and responsibilities to the community anymore. For that matter, they don’t even learn to think anymore either.

      • October 7, 2011 7:45 pm

        Oh yes, I was just teasing. I guess my smiley didn’t convey that. And your completely right on that. In fact I had brought up that point to hopefully start a conversation on the forum I just booted yesterday, maybe you could join me there and chat more about it? – http://silvacollo.hoop.la/forums

        • Heather permalink
          October 7, 2011 7:51 pm

          Nice forum, Rua. Sure, I’d like to chat further on it. :)

Trackbacks

  1. Upcoming work « Humanistic Paganism
  2. Upcoming work « Humanistic Paganism
  3. Mythology poetry | Rapidrefillwas

Comments are closed.

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 611 other followers

%d bloggers like this: